422 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE, Eagles Mere, PA 17731

$1,550,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 6 Square Footage: 5,798 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 50,094 Status: Closed
Current Price: $1,550,000 List Date: 12/05/2025 Last Modified: 2/20/2026

Overview

Description

Experience lakefront living at its finest in this beautifully crafted Arts & Crafts-style home, perfectly situated on Eagles Mere Lake. Designed for comfort and effortless entertaining, this 5-bedroom, 6-bath residence offers exceptional space and custom features. The main level features a first-floor primary ensuite, a library/game room with fireplace, and a private office with custom built-ins. The chef-inspired kitchen boasts quartz countertops, a butler's pantry, two dishwashers, and two refrigerators, opening seamlessly to a spacious dining area ideal for large gatherings. Upstairs, a generous bonus room offers flexibility for guests and/or additional lounge space. The lower level is designed for fun and functionality with a larger recreation area, full bath, sauna, workshop space,

Listing Details MLS# WB-102898

Contract Information

Auction
No
Listing Contract Date
2025-12-04
Assessed Valuation
937200
Listing Service
Full Service
Foreclosure
No

Sold Information

Under Contract Date
2025-12-17
Sold Date
2026-02-13

General Property Description

Apx Abv Gr Fin SqFt
4880
Apx Below GrFin SqFt
918
Apx Total Fin SqFt
5798
Year Built
1992
Lot Size Acres
1.15
Stories
2
Total 1st Floor Baths
3.5
Total Abv. Gr. Rooms
30
Rooms Total
30
Bedrooms Total
5
Bathrooms Full
4
Bathrooms Half
2
Bathrooms Total
6

LocationTax and Other Information

House #
422
Street Name
PENNSYLVANIA
Street Suffix
AVENUE
County
Sullivan
State
PA
Postal Code
17731
MLS Area
SULLIVAN COUNTY
Zoning
R-1
Subdivision Name
Other
Tax ID
05-001-0058

Basement

Basement Access
Walk In

More Information

Details

Property Assoc.
No
Under Construction
No
Home Warranty
No
New Construction
No

Garage Type

Attached
3

Heating Info

Age of System
2023

Land Use

Leased Lot
No
Current OGM Lease
No

Location

Other
on the lake

Lot Description

Frontage
lake

Roof Type

Year
2015

Showings

Media Permission
Yes
Showing Instructions
lockbox

Style

Other
Arts/Crafts Style

Property Features

Appliances Included: Built-In Electric Oven; Cooktop; Dehumidifier; Dishwasher; Disposal; Dryer; Freezer; Garage Door Opener; Microwave Built-In; Range; Range Hood; Refrigerator; Smoke Det; UV Light; Washer; Water Trtmnt System Attic: Access/Scuttle Basement: Full; Exterior Entry; Partially Finished; Sump Pump Cell Service Avail: Cell Service Avail Yes Construction: Frame Cooling: Central Air Dining: Formal Separate Driveway: Other Electrical Service: 200 or Greater Amps Exterior Features: Deck; Porch Screened Exterior Finish: Wood Siding Financing Considered: Cash; Conventional Fireplace: Gas-Propane Floors: Carpet W/W; Wood Foundation: Concrete Perimeter Heating Type: Hot Water Heating Fuel: Oil; Propane Interior Features: Vault Ceiling; Ceiling Fans; Fireplace; Laundry 1st Floor; Master Bath; Pantry; Walk In Closet(s); Wood Floors Internet Avail: Cable; Satellite; High Speed Kitchen Counters: Granite/Quartz/Stone Location: Residential Recreation: Lake/Creek Privileges Roof Type: Shingle Sewer: Public Sewer Site Amenities: Paved Streets/Road Stories: 2+ Stories Television Avail: Cable View: Water; Woods Water Feature: Lake; Lake Access Water Heater: Oil Water Source: Well Windows: Original Contingency Reason: Inspections

Room Information

Room Name Level Length Width
Foyer Main 6.00 16.00
Office Main 9.00 6.00
Three-Quarter Bathroom Main 9.00 5.00
Full Bathroom Main 11.00 7.00
Primary Bedroom Main 17.00 11.00
En Suite Main 11.00 12.00
Bedroom 2 Main 12.00 10.00
Bedroom 3 Main 13.00 10.00
Laundry Main 5.00 6.00
Library Main 16.00 17.00
Living Room Main 25.00 22.00
Porch 1 Main 21.00 11.00
Office Main 21.00 11.00
Pantry Main 10.00 8.00
Laundry Main 9.00 8.00
Half Bathroom Main 6.00 6.00
Kitchen Main 21.00 13.00
Garage1 Main 31.00 24.00
Bonus Room Upper 24.00 14.00
Bedroom 4 Upper 12.00 12.00
Bedroom 5 Upper 17.00 9.00
Full Bathroom Upper 8.00 7.00
Family Room Lower 31.00 22.00
Full Bathroom Lower 17.00 8.00
Bonus Room Lower 15.00 12.00
Work Shop Lower 22.00 15.00
Storage Room Lower 19.00 14.00
Utility Room Lower 15.00 15.00
Storage Room Lower 33.00 39.00
Storage Room Lower 14.00 17.00
Listing Office: COMPASS
Listing Agent: Betsi Way
717-314-0644
Last Updated: February - 20 - 2026
All information deemed reliable, though not guaranteed. All measurements are approximate.